Home »opinion »editorial »Passing the buck...
  • Small - Large
  • |
  • Print
  • |
  • Email
  • |
  • |
  • |
  • Mar 07, 2013 - 3:21 PM
  • |
  • |
  • Report a Typo or Correction

Passing the buck

Canada has no national housing strategy.
And our MP, Tony Clement, wants to keep it that way.
Last week Clement was the spokesperson for the Conservative government as yet another private members bill bit the dust. It seems a complete waste of time and money to even discuss private members bills in the current majority – if it’s not Conservative, it’s getting killed on the floor.
Bill C400, the Secure, Adequate, Accessible and Affordable Housing for Canadians Act takes over from a previous bill which passed first and second reading before Parliament recessed in 2011. It was a good idea then, but now two years later it gets flushed without ceremony.
Antipoverty groups around the country supported the enactment, which would have started the dialogue needed to establish a national housing strategy. For 20 years we did have a national housing plan, but in the 1990s programs were dismantled and downloaded to the provinces. And the provinces have launched a number of initiatives but without the funding to fully address the issue.
The UN says we have a problem. They gave Canada a failing grade in 2009 in terms of people’s right to housing and we’re up for a review this year. Critics say that without a national housing plan we’re bound to fail again.
In a display of partisan politics, Clement called the bill a reckless NDP idea that would plunge the country into financial insolvency. Same threat, different day. Any time the government wants us to do the good-little-citizens-are-seen-but-not-heard routine, they pull out the same old stick. We need them to do the thinking for us all – without their prudence we’re headed for disaster.
And it’s a matter best dealt with at the provincial level, according to Clement. He seems to like nothing more than to throw up his hands and blame the provinces, particularly Liberal Ontario, for failing to meet their mandate.
Giving us a primer on Canadian government structure he points out that we’re the only G8 country that has strong provinces with constitutional responsibilities: education, health care and social housing to name a few.
The timing is interesting. On page 3, Rick Williams laments the future for the ever-growing number of seniors in Muskoka. Among the many costly problems an aging population will face, adequate, affordable housing is at the top of the list.
And also on page 3, we hear about International Woman’s Day coming up on Friday. Women and their children, living in poverty, is another segment in need of that same secure and accessible housing.
But these aren’t problems the feds are ready to face; that buck’s been passed to the provinces and a national strategy is no longer up for discussion.



  • Small - Large
  • |
  • Print
  • |
  • Email
  • |
  • |
More Stories

Editorial

Taxing ganja

Police from five different units of the OPP busted a couple of middle-aged people with possession of 24 grams of weed and a pipe in Foots Bay last week. The street value of the pot was estimated to be about $240. We’re guessing that it cost a lot more than a couple of hundred bucks for officers from the Bracebridge detachment of the Ontario Provincial Police, the OPP West Parry Sound Crime Unit, the OPP Community Drug Action Team, the OPP Organized Crime Enforcement Bureau Drug Enforcement Unit and the OPP K-9 to execute the search warrant. It’s likely the search warrant alone cost more to apply for and obtain. There are levels of bureaucracy to go through, and we all know that bureaucracy is costly at every level. We don’t blame the police for wasting our money, it’s not their fault. They don’t choose which laws they’re going to enforce – that’s a job for the people making the laws. And it’s time for them to give their heads a shake. Prohibition doesn’t work; never has, never will. Sixty-five per cent of Canadians want marijuana laws changed. The earliest remains of human settlement show evidence of recreational drugs. Gorillas and apes have a taste for hallucinogens and stimulants. Primates want to get high and no government is going to stop them. Certainly there are social problems that go along with the abuse of any drug, whether it’s vodka or marijuana. Criminalizing the huge numbers of Canadians who want to smoke some herb doesn’t help solve those problems. Making headway with drug abuse will only happen when it’s treated as a health issue, rather than a legal one. We recognize that not everyone will agree with us; we expect some people to disagree vehemently. But social policy aside, this is a financial issue. It’s not just a moral issue, it’s a matter of dollars and cents. Or is that common sense? As Muskoka Algonquin Healthcare tells us, it’s a fairy tale to imagine that we will have the same level of health care services at our hospitals with an aging population; as the numbers of people requiring help from our food banks rapidly increase; as our municipality struggles to make due with significantly less funds from the province; and as our police services are straining at the seams, in part because they are dealing with more and more people with mental health issues. Something’s got to give.